Scott Barzilla’s Presentation Part I
at the 4th Annual SABR Rogers Hornsby Chapter Winter Meeting, Jan. 23, 2010
at Texas State University-San Marcos
Catchers
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Johnny Bench |
118.67 |
105.9 |
71.2 |
92.33 |
89.1 |
59.5 |
536.7 |
Gary Carter |
112.33 |
98.9 |
66.2 |
87.67 |
85 |
58 |
508.1 |
Yogi Berra |
125 |
90.1 |
61.6 |
92 |
70.1 |
49.2 |
488 |
Ivan Rodriguez |
108.67 |
100.5 |
66.6 |
76 |
82.1 |
50.1 |
483.97 |
Carlton Fisk |
122.67 |
93.4 |
67.5 |
80 |
62.2 |
47.5 |
473.27 |
Mike Piazza |
109 |
77.4 |
59.1 |
90 |
69.1 |
51.9 |
456.5 |
Bill Dickey |
104.67 |
88.5 |
54.3 |
78.33 |
67.9 |
44.2 |
437.9 |
Joe Torre |
105 |
80.4 |
55.5 |
81.33 |
66.5 |
45.4 |
434.13 |
Gabby Hartnett |
108.33 |
91.2 |
50.1 |
76.33 |
67.8 |
39.5 |
433.26 |
Mickey Cochrane |
91.67 |
70.1 |
51.1 |
83.33 |
65.6 |
47.2 |
409 |
Ted Simmons |
105 |
63.5 |
50.8 |
80 |
53.8 |
46.2 |
399.3 |
Buck Ewing |
80.33 |
83.4 |
51.4 |
65.33 |
71.7 |
43.8 |
395.96 |
Jorge Posada |
81.67 |
63.9 |
44.3 |
74.67 |
61 |
43.1 |
368.64 |
Gene Tenace |
77 |
58.6 |
48.6 |
69 |
54.4 |
45.1 |
352.7 |
Bill Freehan |
89 |
57.6 |
43.4 |
74.67 |
48.9 |
38.9 |
352.47 |
Lance Parrish |
82.67 |
67.9 |
35.6 |
64.67 |
56.6 |
32.1 |
339.54 |
Thurman Munson |
68.67 |
57.9 |
43.3 |
68 |
57.1 |
42.9 |
337.87 |
Jason Kendall |
79.33 |
54.7 |
37.1 |
65.33 |
52.8 |
36.4 |
325.66 |
Roy Campanella |
69 |
56.1 |
36.3 |
69 |
56.1 |
36.3 |
322.8 |
Roger Bresnahan |
77 |
52.7 |
42.2 |
65.33 |
45.9 |
37.8 |
320.93 |
Wally Schang |
81.67 |
57.4 |
43.7 |
57.33 |
40.2 |
33 |
313.3 |
Darrell Porter |
74 |
53 |
40.7 |
60.33 |
46.6 |
35.9 |
310.53 |
Charlie Bennett |
52.33 |
70.2 |
37.7 |
43.67 |
63.5 |
33.9 |
301.3 |
Ernie Lombardi |
72.67 |
55.1 |
39 |
55.67 |
44.9 |
30.9 |
298.24 |
Ray Schalk |
63.67 |
54.2 |
22.6 |
55.67 |
51.5 |
22.6 |
270.24 |
Rick Ferrell |
68.66 |
45.8 |
22.9 |
50 |
35.4 |
20.1 |
242.86 |
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Lou Gehrig |
163 |
113.7 |
118.3 |
128 |
92.6 |
96.4 |
712 |
Jimmie Foxx |
145 |
94 |
94 |
108.33 |
74.1 |
76.1 |
591.53 |
Frank Thomas |
135 |
105.3 |
75.9 |
100 |
83.1 |
60.2 |
559.5 |
Jeff Bagwell |
129 |
97.2 |
79.9 |
99.33 |
80.8 |
65.7 |
551.93 |
Cap Anson |
127 |
115 |
99.2 |
76 |
66.2 |
59.3 |
542.7 |
Roger Connor |
121 |
102 |
87.1 |
86.33 |
74.7 |
66.6 |
537.73 |
Dan Brouthers |
118.33 |
92.8 |
83.7 |
89.33 |
75.5 |
67.5 |
527.16 |
Eddie Murray |
145.67 |
96.4 |
66.7 |
91 |
69.2 |
51.8 |
520.77 |
Johnny Mize |
112.67 |
80.2 |
70.1 |
98.67 |
72.6 |
64.4 |
498.64 |
Rafael Palmeiro |
131.33 |
96.1 |
65.7 |
85.67 |
61.3 |
49.9 |
490 |
Willie McCovey |
136 |
74 |
65.1 |
95 |
63.9 |
54.8 |
488.8 |
Mark McGwire |
114 |
79.9 |
63.2 |
94.33 |
68.1 |
55.3 |
474.83 |
Dick Allen |
114 |
70 |
61.1 |
101.33 |
65.4 |
58.5 |
470.33 |
Harmon Killebrew |
123.67 |
70.9 |
61.2 |
93 |
58.5 |
51.2 |
458.47 |
Jim Thome |
117.33 |
69 |
66.9 |
87.67 |
53.9 |
55 |
449.8 |
Keith Hernandez |
110.33 |
69.1 |
61 |
86 |
62.1 |
53.7 |
442.23 |
Will Clark |
110.33 |
74.4 |
57.4 |
89.67 |
61.9 |
47.3 |
441 |
John Olerud |
100.33 |
80 |
56.6 |
79 |
63.9 |
49.2 |
429.03 |
Tony Perez |
116.33 |
69.1 |
50.3 |
83 |
55.1 |
44.9 |
418.73 |
Fred McGriff |
114 |
65.6 |
50.5 |
81 |
52.5 |
45.3 |
408.9 |
Hank Greenberg |
89 |
58.9 |
56.9 |
87.33 |
58.3 |
56.2 |
406.63 |
Orlando Cepeda |
103.33 |
65.1 |
46.6 |
83.67 |
57.4 |
42.6 |
398.7 |
Jason Giambi |
103 |
51.2 |
52.7 |
89.67 |
48.7 |
50.7 |
395.97 |
Bill Terry |
92.67 |
53.9 |
55.3 |
86.33 |
51.7 |
54.4 |
394.3 |
Jake Beckley |
106 |
67.4 |
61.4 |
64.67 |
48.5 |
43.4 |
391.37 |
George Sisler |
97.33 |
50.3 |
50.4 |
79.67 |
53.3 |
51.9 |
382.9 |
Frank Chance |
79 |
47.7 |
49.4 |
71 |
42.9 |
45.1 |
335.1 |
Jim Bottomley |
86 |
38.5 |
32.3 |
71.33 |
37.9 |
33.1 |
299.13 |
George Kelly |
64.33 |
23.6 |
24.1 |
59.33 |
25.7 |
26.3 |
223.36 |
Second Basemen
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Eddie Collins |
191.33 |
137.8 |
126.7 |
125.33 |
96.3 |
87.6 |
765.06 |
Rogers Hornsby |
167.33 |
128.6 |
127.7 |
127 |
101.3 |
100.8 |
752.73 |
Joe Morgan |
170.67 |
127.4 |
103.5 |
113.67 |
91.8 |
78.1 |
685.14 |
Nap Lajoie |
165.33 |
125.9 |
104.1 |
111.33 |
93.1 |
75.4 |
675.16 |
Charlie Gehringer |
127.67 |
84.7 |
80.9 |
97 |
69.7 |
67 |
526.97 |
Craig Biggio |
142.67 |
90 |
65.9 |
98 |
67.8 |
52.4 |
516.77 |
Rod Carew |
128 |
85.8 |
79.3 |
87 |
67 |
61.3 |
508.4 |
Frankie Frisch |
122 |
83.3 |
74.7 |
85.33 |
65.3 |
60 |
490.63 |
Bobby Grich |
109.67 |
92.4 |
67.6 |
84.33 |
79.1 |
55.9 |
489 |
Lou Whitaker |
117 |
103.3 |
69.6 |
77.33 |
69.9 |
48.1 |
485.23 |
Roberto Alomar |
123.67 |
81 |
63.6 |
92.67 |
69.9 |
53.1 |
483.94 |
Ryne Sandberg |
115.33 |
75.8 |
61.8 |
93 |
68.8 |
53.9 |
468.63 |
Jeff Kent |
113 |
80 |
59.4 |
83.33 |
61.4 |
47.1 |
444.23 |
Jackie Robinson |
85.67 |
67.9 |
63 |
85.67 |
67.9 |
63 |
433.14 |
Billy Herman |
99.33 |
77.8 |
55.5 |
81 |
66.5 |
46.4 |
426.53 |
Willie Randolph |
104 |
70.7 |
60.4 |
73.67 |
56.4 |
45.8 |
410.97 |
Bid McPhee |
101.67 |
77.7 |
57.8 |
67.33 |
53.5 |
46.2 |
404.2 |
Joe Gordon |
80.67 |
67.4 |
54.9 |
77.67 |
65.8 |
53.6 |
400.04 |
Bobby Doerr |
93.67 |
72.7 |
48 |
78 |
62.2 |
43.3 |
397.87 |
Nellie Fox |
101.33 |
63.4 |
44.6 |
73.33 |
60.2 |
42.6 |
385.46 |
Tony Phillips |
89.33 |
69.1 |
47.8 |
66.33 |
59.4 |
40.1 |
372.06 |
Cupid Childs |
79.67 |
58.4 |
47.1 |
75.33 |
55.9 |
46.4 |
362.8 |
Tony Lazzeri |
84 |
57.9 |
48.1 |
71.67 |
54.2 |
42.6 |
358.47 |
Chuck Knoblauch |
78 |
57.4 |
41.1 |
73 |
57.8 |
41.8 |
349.1 |
Larry Doyle |
96.33 |
41.7 |
47.3 |
80 |
37.7 |
40.5 |
343.53 |
Johnny Evers |
89.33 |
46 |
48.3 |
75.33 |
42.5 |
39.4 |
340.86 |
Red Schoendienst |
87.33 |
57.9 |
40.3 |
68 |
48 |
35.9 |
337.43 |
Bill Mazeroski |
73 |
51.5 |
27 |
57.67 |
46.2 |
25.9 |
281.27 |
Third Basemen
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Mike Schmidt |
155.67 |
122.7 |
108 |
122 |
92.5 |
81.9 |
682.77 |
Eddie Mathews |
150 |
122.2 |
98.2 |
111 |
96 |
75.8 |
653.2 |
Wade Boggs |
131.33 |
116.6 |
89 |
97 |
90.4 |
71.1 |
595.43 |
George Brett |
144 |
112.4 |
84.9 |
98.67 |
82.6 |
67.7 |
590.27 |
Paul Molitor |
138 |
108.8 |
74.9 |
90 |
75.1 |
54.2 |
541 |
Chipper Jones |
123 |
72.4 |
76.7 |
83.67 |
59.6 |
60.9 |
476.27 |
Ron Santo |
108 |
72.7 |
66.4 |
91.67 |
70.5 |
63.4 |
472.67 |
Edgar Martinez |
101.67 |
88.2 |
67.2 |
81.67 |
72.4 |
58.1 |
469.24 |
Brooks Robinson |
118.67 |
70.3 |
69.2 |
82.33 |
58.1 |
54.8 |
453.4 |
Frank Baker |
100.33 |
69.6 |
63.7 |
93.33 |
65.6 |
60.3 |
452.86 |
Robin Ventura |
91.33 |
96.6 |
55.1 |
77.76 |
80 |
46.7 |
447.49 |
Graig Nettles |
107 |
80.2 |
61.3 |
74.67 |
59.2 |
49.9 |
432.27 |
Darrell Evans |
121 |
62.1 |
57 |
84.33 |
53.1 |
51.9 |
429.43 |
Stan Hack |
105.33 |
74.4 |
54.8 |
85.33 |
61.9 |
45.7 |
427.46 |
Jimmy Collins |
91.33 |
68.7 |
52.9 |
80.67 |
64.7 |
49.5 |
407.8 |
Scott Rolen |
91 |
74.7 |
62.2 |
81.33 |
63.5 |
53.3 |
426.03 |
Sal Bando |
94.33 |
56.3 |
60.5 |
83.67 |
54.3 |
57.2 |
406.3 |
Ken Boyer |
93 |
62 |
58.3 |
78.33 |
56.2 |
53.7 |
401.53 |
Bob Elliott |
95.67 |
66.3 |
52.2 |
78.67 |
58.2 |
45.7 |
396.74 |
Buddy Bell |
100.33 |
63.2 |
60.7 |
70 |
53.6 |
45.3 |
393.13 |
Heinie Groh |
90.67 |
68.8 |
46.4 |
81 |
59.3 |
43.8 |
389.97 |
Ron Cey |
93.33 |
55 |
51.8 |
74 |
51.7 |
46.2 |
372.03 |
Toby Harrah |
95.67 |
54.7 |
47 |
75.67 |
52 |
42.5 |
367.54 |
Pie Traynor |
91.33 |
63.9 |
37 |
76 |
56.1 |
38.1 |
362.43 |
John McGraw |
69 |
54.5 |
49.1 |
66.67 |
53.6 |
48 |
340.87 |
George Kell |
76.33 |
40.4 |
33.5 |
64 |
36.1 |
31.8 |
282.13 |
Shortstop
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Honus Wagner |
218.33 |
158.7 |
134.7 |
140.67 |
104 |
92.6 |
849 |
Alex Rodriguez |
140.67 |
101 |
99.1 |
109.67 |
81.6 |
82.1 |
614.14 |
Cal Ripken Jr. |
142.33 |
113.5 |
89.8 |
92 |
76.1 |
67.5 |
581.23 |
Robin Yount |
141 |
104.5 |
76.8 |
92.67 |
80.5 |
59.2 |
554.67 |
Arky Vaughan |
118.67 |
100.3 |
75.6 |
102.67 |
87.7 |
66.7 |
551.64 |
George Davis |
132.67 |
94.4 |
90.7 |
85 |
68.5 |
63.1 |
534.37 |
Barry Larkin |
115.67 |
98.8 |
68.8 |
86 |
83 |
54.8 |
507.07 |
Luke Appling |
126 |
86.7 |
68.9 |
91.67 |
68.4 |
56.1 |
497.77 |
Bill Dahlen |
131.33 |
88.5 |
75.9 |
83.33 |
60.6 |
53 |
492.66 |
Monte Ward |
136.33 |
73.7 |
64.5 |
102.67 |
60.3 |
49.3 |
486.8 |
Ozzie Smith |
108.33 |
105.5 |
64.7 |
75.33 |
78.2 |
50.4 |
482.46 |
Alan Trammel |
106 |
93.6 |
66.8 |
79.33 |
74 |
56 |
475.73 |
Joe Cronin |
111 |
78.7 |
62.6 |
91.67 |
69.7 |
54 |
467.67 |
Ernie Banks |
110.67 |
74.8 |
64.3 |
82.33 |
67.6 |
60 |
459.7 |
Derek Jeter |
116 |
61.4 |
68.7 |
91 |
51 |
57.6 |
445.7 |
Lou Boudreau |
92.33 |
82.6 |
55.9 |
85 |
75.9 |
53 |
444.73 |
Bobby Wallace |
115 |
72.8 |
65.8 |
75.67 |
60.4 |
50.5 |
440.17 |
Pee Wee Reese |
104.67 |
71.3 |
66.4 |
82 |
57.7 |
55.1 |
437.17 |
Jack Glasscock |
87 |
74.1 |
58.1 |
67.67 |
60.4 |
47.8 |
395.07 |
Joe Sewell |
92.33 |
62.7 |
48.1 |
77.67 |
55.8 |
42.7 |
379.3 |
Tony Fernandez |
93.33 |
71.6 |
39.4 |
73 |
59.3 |
34.6 |
371.23 |
Luis Aparicio |
97.67 |
57.4 |
49.8 |
64.33 |
49 |
39 |
357.2 |
Dave Bancroft |
89.67 |
51.7 |
46.3 |
74 |
47 |
44.1 |
352.77 |
Vern Stephens |
88.33 |
50.5 |
43.4 |
79.67 |
47.9 |
39.5 |
349.3 |
Hughie Jennings |
71.33 |
56.5 |
47.9 |
68 |
55.7 |
48.4 |
347.83 |
Joe Tinker |
86 |
51.8 |
49 |
70.33 |
45 |
41.4 |
343.53 |
Phil Rizzuto |
77 |
53.2 |
41.6 |
72.67 |
50.5 |
40.8 |
335.77 |
Rabbit Maranville |
100.67 |
49.6 |
38 |
69 |
41.8 |
34.3 |
333.37 |
Travis Jackson |
70.33 |
47.3 |
43.3 |
63.67 |
49.1 |
43.5 |
317.2 |
Left Fielders
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Barry Bonds |
234.67 |
192.6 |
171.4 |
142 |
119.6 |
106.6 |
966.87 |
Stan Musial |
201.33 |
152.8 |
127.9 |
126 |
100.6 |
86.2 |
794.83 |
Ted Williams |
185 |
128.2 |
125 |
131.33 |
97.2 |
93.4 |
760.13 |
Rickey Henderson |
178.33 |
155.8 |
113.1 |
102.67 |
95 |
74.1 |
719 |
Pete Rose |
182.33 |
106.4 |
75.4 |
102.33 |
73.7 |
58.5 |
598.66 |
Carl Yastrzemski |
162.67 |
94.8 |
88.5 |
95.33 |
63 |
64.5 |
568.8 |
Ed Delahanty |
118.33 |
84.7 |
74.6 |
97.67 |
77 |
70.9 |
523.2 |
Tim Rains |
130 |
94.2 |
64.9 |
91.67 |
65.3 |
51.4 |
497.47 |
Fred Clarke |
133.33 |
81.1 |
73.4 |
91.33 |
57.4 |
53.8 |
490.36 |
Jesse Burkett |
129.67 |
73.3 |
63.8 |
94.33 |
60.9 |
52.8 |
474.8 |
Manny Ramirez |
132.33 |
73.1 |
66.2 |
95 |
53.3 |
50.7 |
470.63 |
Al Simmons |
125 |
71.4 |
63.5 |
95.33 |
59.2 |
55.5 |
469.93 |
Willie Stargell |
123.33 |
82.2 |
57.5 |
87.67 |
66.4 |
47.8 |
464.9 |
Joe Jackson |
98 |
60.1 |
62.9 |
96.67 |
56.4 |
61.6 |
435.67 |
Goose Goslin |
118.33 |
61.8 |
62.9 |
87.67 |
52.9 |
51 |
434.6 |
Billy Williams |
124.67 |
59.3 |
57.2 |
93 |
49.5 |
48 |
431.67 |
Sherry Magee |
118 |
59.4 |
59.1 |
90.67 |
51.4 |
49 |
427.57 |
Joe Medwick |
104 |
67 |
56 |
89 |
60 |
50.5 |
426.5 |
Zack Wheat |
126.67 |
61.8 |
57.7 |
88 |
48 |
43.5 |
425.67 |
Jose Cruz |
104.33 |
72.7 |
52.3 |
79.67 |
60.6 |
44.2 |
413.8 |
Jim O’Rourke |
101.67 |
94.4 |
54 |
65.67 |
62.4 |
35.1 |
413.24 |
Jimmy Sheckard |
113 |
63.9 |
51.7 |
85.67 |
55 |
42.6 |
411.87 |
Joe Kelley |
101.67 |
59.9 |
55.4 |
80.67 |
56.6 |
49.8 |
404.04 |
Lou Brock |
116 |
54.4 |
39.1 |
85.67 |
46.6 |
35.7 |
377.47 |
Albert Belle |
81 |
61.9 |
37.1 |
79 |
62.1 |
37.6 |
358.7 |
Jim Rice |
94 |
55.1 |
41.5 |
77.67 |
50.2 |
39.9 |
358.37 |
Ralph Kiner |
80.67 |
47.9 |
45.8 |
80.67 |
47.9 |
45.8 |
348.74 |
Heinie Manush |
95 |
31.1 |
43.9 |
78.67 |
31.9 |
39.3 |
319.87 |
Chick Hafey |
62 |
31.8 |
29.4 |
58.67 |
32.2 |
30.2 |
244.27 |