Scott Barzilla’s Presentation Part II
at the 4th Annual SABR Rogers Hornsby Chapter Winter Meeting, Jan. 23, 2010
at Texas State University-San Marcos
Centerfield
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Ty Cobb |
240.67 |
158.5 |
159.3 |
139.67 |
100.4 |
97.3 |
895.84 |
Willie Mays |
214 |
177.6 |
154.7 |
129.67 |
111.1 |
99.7 |
886.77 |
Tris Speaker |
210 |
143.7 |
132.8 |
129.33 |
94 |
86.2 |
796.03 |
Mickey Mantle |
188.33 |
124.9 |
120.2 |
133 |
95.5 |
90.9 |
752.83 |
Joe DiMaggio |
129 |
101.2 |
83.4 |
108.33 |
85.8 |
66.1 |
573.83 |
Ken Griffey Jr |
134.33 |
79.7 |
79.2 |
92 |
64.6 |
68.2 |
518.03 |
Billy Hamilton |
112.33 |
78.3 |
69.6 |
94.33 |
69.6 |
61.7 |
485.86 |
Duke Snider |
117.33 |
66.8 |
67.2 |
96.33 |
58.8 |
60.4 |
466.86 |
Jim Edmonds |
97.67 |
82.5 |
66.6 |
83 |
73.5 |
61.4 |
464.67 |
Richie Ashburn |
109.67 |
76.2 |
58 |
84.67 |
65.9 |
53.4 |
447.84 |
Jimmy Wynn |
101.67 |
68.2 |
59.8 |
89.67 |
66.9 |
58.3 |
444.54 |
Bernie Williams |
104 |
78.9 |
47.1 |
82.67 |
71.2 |
45.3 |
429.17 |
Cesar Cedeno |
98.67 |
70.6 |
52.1 |
78.67 |
61.6 |
47.5 |
409.14 |
Brett Butler |
98.33 |
76.9 |
46.5 |
76.33 |
63.2 |
43.1 |
404.36 |
Andruw Jones |
85 |
61.3 |
58.4 |
77 |
59.1 |
58.5 |
399.3 |
Max Carey |
117 |
59.1 |
50.6 |
81.67 |
48.4 |
41.3 |
398.07 |
Vada Pinson |
107 |
57.7 |
49 |
82 |
51.9 |
45.9 |
393.5 |
Tommy Leach |
109.33 |
60 |
51 |
82 |
49.9 |
40.4 |
392.63 |
Kirby Puckett |
93.67 |
66.5 |
45 |
82.33 |
61.4 |
42.2 |
391.1 |
Larry Doby |
89.33 |
57.7 |
47.4 |
85.67 |
56.7 |
47.1 |
383.9 |
High Duffy |
98.33 |
55 |
49.6 |
83.67 |
49.3 |
44.4 |
380.3 |
George Van Haltren |
114.67 |
52.3 |
45.9 |
80 |
45.1 |
37.5 |
375.47 |
Earl Averill |
93.33 |
49.8 |
45.2 |
89.33 |
50.2 |
45.2 |
373.06 |
Dale Murphy |
98 |
50.1 |
44.4 |
83 |
48.9 |
45.9 |
370.3 |
Edd Roush |
104.67 |
49.4 |
46.8 |
83.33 |
44.6 |
41 |
369.8 |
Hack Wilson |
74.67 |
42.8 |
38.8 |
73.33 |
43.4 |
39.8 |
312.8 |
Earle Combs |
75.67 |
39 |
44.6 |
72.33 |
37.6 |
43.5 |
312.7 |
Lloyd Waner |
81.67 |
38.6 |
24.1 |
69 |
34.8 |
25.4 |
273.57 |
Right Fielders
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Babe Ruth |
252 |
198.7 |
190 |
153.33 |
125 |
122 |
1041 |
Hank Aaron |
214.33 |
159.4 |
141.5 |
118.67 |
98.7 |
84.3 |
816.9 |
Mel Ott |
176 |
141.4 |
109.2 |
111.67 |
95.5 |
73.6 |
707.37 |
Frank Robinson |
173 |
126.1 |
107.1 |
105.33 |
81.9 |
69.3 |
662.73 |
Reggie Jackson |
148 |
93.5 |
74.4 |
98.67 |
70.9 |
61.7 |
547.17 |
Al Kaline |
147.67 |
89.5 |
90.8 |
89.33 |
65.5 |
63.9 |
546.7 |
Paul Waner |
141 |
90 |
73.8 |
101.33 |
69.6 |
58.2 |
533.93 |
Sam Crawford |
148.67 |
80.6 |
76.3 |
101 |
61.1 |
55 |
522.67 |
Roberto Clemente |
125.67 |
82.7 |
83.6 |
89.67 |
63.4 |
65.4 |
510.44 |
Tony Gwynn |
132.67 |
97.6 |
68.5 |
89.67 |
70.6 |
50.1 |
509.14 |
Gary Sheffield |
143.33 |
79.7 |
63.3 |
100 |
61.7 |
51.5 |
499.53 |
Dave Winfield |
138.33 |
85.2 |
59.7 |
86.33 |
57.2 |
47.1 |
473.86 |
Harry Heilmann |
118.67 |
67.7 |
69.3 |
90.33 |
57.7 |
57.7 |
461.4 |
Willie Keeler |
111 |
76.9 |
60.7 |
82 |
66.6 |
52 |
449.2 |
Elmer Flick |
97 |
72.8 |
56.6 |
93.33 |
72.1 |
55.7 |
447.53 |
Sammy Sosa |
107 |
69.6 |
59.5 |
84.67 |
59.8 |
55.2 |
435.77 |
Dwight Evans |
115.67 |
70.5 |
61.7 |
78 |
54.8 |
46.2 |
426.87 |
Bobby Bonds |
100.67 |
65.2 |
56.9 |
88 |
60 |
51.8 |
422.57 |
Reggie Smith |
108.33 |
63.5 |
63.2 |
83.33 |
50.8 |
50.5 |
419.66 |
Enos Slaughter |
107.67 |
72.1 |
54.1 |
82 |
59.1 |
44.2 |
419.17 |
Andre Dawson |
113.33 |
66.1 |
56.8 |
78 |
57 |
47.2 |
418.43 |
Larry Walker |
102.67 |
63.8 |
67.1 |
78 |
53 |
53.3 |
417.87 |
King Kelly |
92.67 |
85.1 |
47.4 |
73 |
69.8 |
45.6 |
413.57 |
Rusty Staub |
119.33 |
63.9 |
45 |
84.67 |
50.3 |
40.1 |
403.3 |
Vladimir Guerrero |
100.33 |
53.3 |
57.1 |
88.67 |
49 |
53.2 |
401.6 |
Bobby Abreu |
104 |
57.1 |
57 |
81 |
51.1 |
51.3 |
401.5 |
Kiki Cuyler |
97.33 |
57.1 |
49.7 |
81.33 |
51.2 |
46 |
382.66 |
Harry Hooper |
107 |
57.4 |
52.3 |
73.67 |
47.4 |
40.6 |
378.37 |
Sam Rice |
109 |
50.6 |
51 |
76 |
40.7 |
40 |
367.3 |
Sam Thompson |
78.67 |
65.5 |
46.5 |
71 |
60.1 |
43 |
364.77 |
Chuck Klein |
79.33 |
44.4 |
39.2 |
72.33 |
45.2 |
38 |
318.46 |
Ross Youngs |
68.67 |
43.5 |
36.2 |
68.67 |
43.5 |
36.2 |
296.74 |
Tommy McCarthy |
56.67 |
15.9 |
18.2 |
56 |
24.8 |
21.8 |
193.37 |
Pitchers
|
WS |
WARP3 |
WAR |
PWS |
PWARP3 |
PWAR |
Total |
Walter Johnson |
186.67 |
172 |
127.7 |
126.67 |
119 |
91.8 |
823.84 |
Cy Young |
211.33 |
140.3 |
146 |
128.33 |
89.7 |
94.9 |
810.56 |
Roger Clemens |
145.67 |
164.5 |
128.4 |
86.67 |
101.4 |
80.6 |
707.24 |
Pete Alexander |
158.67 |
132.2 |
104.9 |
110.33 |
96.4 |
76.3 |
678.8 |
Greg Maddux |
132.67 |
155.6 |
96.8 |
82 |
101.8 |
67.2 |
636.07 |
Kid Nichols |
159.33 |
82.1 |
102.3 |
130.33 |
69.9 |
87.6 |
631.56 |
Christy Mathewson |
142 |
107.9 |
87.7 |
111.67 |
92.5 |
79.2 |
620.97 |
Lefty Grove |
130.33 |
113.9 |
98.3 |
100.33 |
91.4 |
78.1 |
612.36 |
Warren Spahn |
137.33 |
132.4 |
93.4 |
86.33 |
87.9 |
60.1 |
597.46 |
Tom Seaver |
129.33 |
117.9 |
105.3 |
85 |
75.9 |
70.7 |
584.13 |
Phil Niekro |
124.67 |
121.5 |
96.8 |
78.33 |
85.7 |
68.6 |
575.6 |
Tim Keefe |
137.67 |
78.1 |
82.5 |
123 |
71.9 |
78.9 |
572.07 |
John Clarkson |
132 |
74 |
82.1 |
128 |
73.3 |
81.8 |
571.2 |
Randy Johnson |
108.67 |
115 |
91.8 |
76.33 |
87.1 |
72.1 |
551 |
Gaylord Perry |
123 |
91.9 |
96.3 |
81 |
63.4 |
71.3 |
526.9 |
Bob Gibson |
105.67 |
94.9 |
85.6 |
86 |
79.7 |
73.5 |
525.37 |
Steve Carlton |
122 |
100.3 |
84.4 |
80 |
72.9 |
64.6 |
524.2 |
Robin Roberts |
113 |
100.6 |
80.9 |
82 |
74.5 |
62.2 |
513.2 |
Pud Galvin |
134.33 |
59.8 |
70.5 |
118.67 |
55.5 |
68.6 |
507.4 |
Charles Radbourn |
130.33 |
52.7 |
71.6 |
127.33 |
52.9 |
71.3 |
506.16 |
Eddie Plank |
120.33 |
83.3 |
76.3 |
86.33 |
66.2 |
55.8 |
488.26 |
Bert Blyleven |
113 |
90.6 |
90.1 |
72.67 |
58.9 |
61.2 |
486.47 |
Pedro Martinez |
85.33 |
98.4 |
75.9 |
69 |
80.6 |
65.6 |
474.83 |
Tom Glavine |
104.67 |
118.5 |
67 |
68 |
65.6 |
47.1 |
470.87 |
Fergie Jenkins |
107.67 |
83.8 |
81.3 |
77.67 |
63.4 |
55.5 |
469.34 |
Carl Hubbell |
101.67 |
88.6 |
64.4 |
82.67 |
74.3 |
55.9 |
467.54 |
Mike Mussina |
90 |
101.9 |
74.8 |
62 |
75.5 |
54.3 |
458.5 |
Tony Mullane |
133 |
34.4 |
65.1 |
122.33 |
39.1 |
62.8 |
456.73 |
Bob Caruthers |
112.33 |
43.2 |
71.4 |
112.33 |
43.2 |
71.4 |
453.86 |
Nolan Ryan |
111.33 |
83.5 |
84.8 |
63.67 |
54.4 |
55.3 |
453 |
Bob Feller |
97.33 |
75.4 |
66 |
79.67 |
68.6 |
61.3 |
448.3 |
Jim McCormick |
111.33 |
48.1 |
64.7 |
111.33 |
46.3 |
63.2 |
444.96 |
John Smoltz |
96.33 |
106.2 |
63.9 |
61.67 |
69 |
45.5 |
442.6 |
Amos Rusie |
97.67 |
61.3 |
60.6 |
97.67 |
61.3 |
60.6 |
439.14 |
Curt Schilling |
84 |
89.6 |
69.7 |
63.67 |
70.9 |
55.9 |
433.77 |
Hal Newhouser |
88 |
81.4 |
56.3 |
78 |
72.7 |
52.6 |
429 |
Ted Lyons |
104 |
85.5 |
58.8 |
70 |
63.1 |
46.4 |
427.8 |
Mickey Welch |
118 |
36.2 |
56.5 |
113 |
38.9 |
62.6 |
425.2 |
Don Drysdale |
86 |
75.2 |
65.7 |
73.67 |
65.5 |
58.2 |
424.27 |
Jim Palmer |
104 |
61.2 |
63.5 |
84 |
53.4 |
57.4 |
423.5 |
Juan Marichal |
87.67 |
68.4 |
64 |
76.33 |
64.1 |
59.7 |
420.2 |
Ed Walsh |
88.33 |
65.8 |
54.8 |
86.33 |
66 |
55.2 |
416.46 |
Jim Bunning |
85.67 |
70.8 |
60.1 |
73.67 |
65.7 |
58.5 |
414.44 |
Rick Reuschel |
80 |
88.6 |
66.3 |
60.33 |
66.9 |
52.1 |
414.23 |
Kevin Brown |
80.67 |
79.6 |
64.8 |
64.67 |
68 |
55.1 |
412.84 |
Dennis Eckersley |
100.33 |
91.1 |
58.7 |
61 |
56.5 |
43.9 |
411.53 |
Early Wynn |
103 |
79.9 |
52 |
72.33 |
59.2 |
44.5 |
410.93 |
Red Ruffing |
107.33 |
78.6 |
53.6 |
70.67 |
55 |
43 |
408.2 |
Dazzy Vance |
80.33 |
72.3 |
56.4 |
72.67 |
68.2 |
53.7 |
403.6 |
Vic Willis |
97.67 |
55.6 |
57.2 |
85.67 |
51.8 |
55.6 |
403.54 |
Don Sutton |
106.33 |
69.9 |
70.8 |
62 |
43.8 |
45.7 |
398.53 |
Stan Coveleski |
81.67 |
67.6 |
54 |
77 |
64.8 |
52.9 |
397.97 |
Charlie Buffinton |
94.33 |
45.6 |
56.1 |
93.67 |
47.3 |
58.4 |
395.4 |
Eppa Rixey |
105 |
71.7 |
51.2 |
72.33 |
51.2 |
42.3 |
393.73 |
Mariano Rivera |
75.67 |
94.4 |
49.9 |
58.33 |
71.9 |
40.2 |
390.4 |
Joe McGinnity |
89.67 |
51.7 |
53.7 |
89.67 |
51.7 |
53 |
389.44 |
Mordecai Brown |
98.67 |
49.2 |
56.1 |
88 |
44 |
51.6 |
387.57 |
Clark Griffith |
91 |
61.1 |
49 |
79.67 |
56.6 |
47.4 |
384.77 |
Red Faber |
97.33 |
67.8 |
55.2 |
68.67 |
50.8 |
42.8 |
382.6 |
Tommy John |
96.33 |
76.7 |
59 |
55.33 |
51.1 |
41 |
379.46 |
Luis Tiant |
85.33 |
64.3 |
60.1 |
66 |
52.6 |
50.8 |
379.13 |
Burleigh Grimes |
95.33 |
68 |
37.2 |
77 |
58.4 |
40.2 |
376.13 |
Jack Quinn |
95.67 |
71.5 |
49.7 |
65 |
49.5 |
39.2 |
370.57 |
Rube Waddell |
80 |
56.6 |
50.2 |
77 |
55.5 |
49.6 |
368.9 |
David Cone |
68.33 |
72.7 |
57.5 |
57.67 |
60.1 |
51 |
367.3 |
Larry Jackson |
75 |
64.4 |
55.6 |
62 |
56.1 |
51.1 |
364.2 |
Whitey Ford |
87 |
61.5 |
55.3 |
67.33 |
48.7 |
44.2 |
364.03 |
Billy Pierce |
82.67 |
62.4 |
53.5 |
64.33 |
51.8 |
47.3 |
362 |
Jack Powell |
95.67 |
59.4 |
44.5 |
75.67 |
46.9 |
38 |
360.14 |
Frank Tanana |
80.33 |
71.3 |
55.1 |
54.67 |
52.4 |
46.3 |
360.1 |
Jerry Koosman |
80 |
60.7 |
58.8 |
60.33 |
48.5 |
48 |
356.33 |
Wilbur Cooper |
88.67 |
50.5 |
43.7 |
79.67 |
49.7 |
42.9 |
355.14 |
Bob Lemon |
77.33 |
60 |
42.4 |
74.33 |
58.6 |
41.9 |
354.56 |
Eddie Cicotte |
82.33 |
55.1 |
49.7 |
70.33 |
50 |
45.8 |
353.26 |
Silver King |
87.67 |
33.7 |
53.8 |
87.67 |
34.5 |
55.4 |
352.74 |
Tommy Bridges |
75 |
63.8 |
50.7 |
63 |
53.9 |
44.7 |
351.1 |
Bret Saberhagen |
64.33 |
69.1 |
54.7 |
55 |
59.5 |
48.1 |
350.73 |
Orel Hershiser |
70 |
68 |
51.5 |
57 |
58 |
44.7 |
349.2 |
Gus Weyhing |
86 |
40.8 |
46.3 |
83 |
38.8 |
52.2 |
347.1 |
Dizzy Trout |
76 |
62.6 |
43.6 |
66.33 |
57.5 |
39.4 |
345.43 |
Chuck Finley |
71.33 |
65.8 |
55 |
54.67 |
51.3 |
46.7 |
344.8 |
Sandy Koufax |
64.67 |
54.3 |
54.5 |
63.33 |
53.5 |
54.1 |
344.4 |
Urban Shocker |
75 |
55.7 |
47 |
70 |
51.7 |
44.5 |
343.9 |
Dutch Leonard |
77.67 |
69.8 |
45.6 |
57 |
55.8 |
37.6 |
343.47 |
Bob Friend |
69 |
66.8 |
48.9 |
56.33 |
57 |
45 |
343.03 |
Bobo Newsom |
79 |
58.2 |
45.9 |
63.67 |
50 |
44 |
340.77 |
Dave Steib |
70 |
53.4 |
53 |
62.33 |
50.2 |
51 |
339.93 |
Waite Hoyt |
87.33 |
58.4 |
47 |
63 |
44.9 |
38.9 |
339.53 |
Kevin Appier |
63 |
60.1 |
50.4 |
55.33 |
57.9 |
50.3 |
337.03 |
Babe Adams |
81 |
47.6 |
45.2 |
68.67 |
46.8 |
47.5 |
336.77 |
Mickey Lolich |
74.67 |
54.8 |
45.6 |
63 |
51 |
45 |
334.07 |
Hoyt Wilhelm |
85.33 |
70.4 |
41.3 |
56 |
48.2 |
29.6 |
330.83 |
Frank Viola |
62.33 |
60.6 |
43.9 |
59.33 |
58.2 |
44.8 |
329.16 |
Dwight Gooden |
62.33 |
65.4 |
47.6 |
52 |
57.6 |
43.6 |
328.53 |
Dennis Martinez |
77.67 |
59.9 |
46.9 |
53 |
48.8 |
42.2 |
328.47 |
Kenny Rogers |
68.33 |
69 |
46.7 |
49.33 |
53.5 |
40.5 |
327.36 |
Jamie Moyer |
73.67 |
66.9 |
47.9 |
49.33 |
49.2 |
38.5 |
325.5 |
Wilbur Wood |
63.33 |
57 |
45 |
58.67 |
55.4 |
45.2 |
324.6 |
Rich Gossage |
74.33 |
62.1 |
40 |
57.67 |
51.5 |
37.2 |
322.8 |
Mark Langston |
61.33 |
60.1 |
47.1 |
54.67 |
53.6 |
43.8 |
320.6 |
Herb Pennock |
80 |
51.5 |
36.9 |
62.67 |
49.3 |
38 |
318.37 |
Dizzy Dean |
60.33 |
56.9 |
39.6 |
60 |
56.9 |
40.5 |
314.23 |
Chief Bender |
77 |
47.1 |
38.5 |
62 |
40.6 |
38.4 |
303.6 |
Lefty Gomez |
61.67 |
43 |
43 |
60.67 |
44.2 |
44.3 |
296.84 |
Addie Joss |
63.67 |
42.3 |
40.9 |
63.67 |
42.3 |
40.9 |
293.74 |
Jack Chesbro |
69.67 |
40.4 |
33.2 |
69.67 |
42 |
36.8 |
291.74 |
Catfish Hunter |
68.67 |
32.5 |
32.5 |
61.33 |
33.6 |
33.5 |
262.1 |
Jesse Haines |
69 |
43.4 |
33.8 |
51.67 |
31.9 |
28.5 |
258.27 |
Bruce Sutter |
56 |
48.8 |
25 |
54.33 |
47.4 |
25.9 |
257.43 |
Rube Marquard |
69.33 |
33.3 |
28.5 |
60 |
33.2 |
32.7 |
257.03 |
Rollie Fingers |
62.67 |
48.5 |
24.4 |
48.67 |
43.2 |
24.3 |
251.74 |